Saturday, March 25, 2006

Racism = Prejudice + Power

My unapologetic intention when I teach is to open students' minds to ideas they may not have previously considered. If this sounds like something scary, keep in mind that the whole process of socialization--from birth--is exactly and nothing more than this. We're not born "gendered," for example; the attempt is made to carefully and with great intent turn us into "little girls" and "little boys"--for life. Similarly, one of the perfectly understandable difficulties with our legislative system is that virtually all of those who make it to Washington were born rich and have really no clue in Hell what the rest of us--the vast majority of U.S. citizens--are dealing with.

Anyway, by the time most young people get to college, they've had at least 18 years of non-stop exposure to the "party line." By this, I don't mean necessarily a particular political view, although that can certainly be part of it. What I mean is that this nation was founded on principles that are very, very intrinsic to its nature and pretty much consistent to the present. And youth being raised up under these principles and impressed with their veracity come to see them as the only way to think. This is what many people call a "world view." Every society has one.

Now, if the principles in question were the principles we hear touted all the time when people are running for office or selling a war--principles such as truth, peace, and freedom--there wouldn't be a problem. And I'd probably be somewhere rocking on a porch. But from the inception of this nation, we have talked out one side of our national mouth and barked orders out of the other without seeming to recognize or care that those to whom we are barking the orders are not confused about our motives one iota.

We rave about truth while telling huge and malicious lies and then simply shrug when confronted with reality. We smarm about freedom and have the hands-down worst reputation of all time for forcing our will on anyone who will stand still for it and literally millions who have fought us to the death (such as the Native Americans)--allies and enemies alike. And we pontificate sanctimoniously about peace while having built and maintained our nation on the back of a military machine that began with men shooting other men in the back from behind trees and has now become a force that will go down in history with the most infamous and misguided despotic societies that ever existed.

So it is that people who have been raised under this system have learned to say that they believe in one thing, and yet actually live their lives out very pointedly in directions that manifest something totally different. Such as, on one hand, screeching "just say no to drugs" at the top of our lungs, while popping every imaginable substance--prescription, street, or otherwise--at every imaginable opportunity. Whether it's crack, valium, Jack Daniels, or Starbucks, we espouse one theory and live another.

Similarly, people in the United States, and most particularly European-Americans, spout a supposed belief in "equality," whatever we think that is, while being unconscionably comfortable with the greatest gaps (between rich and poor, between White and Black) of any industrialized nation of the world. And we are so committed to this idealized belief in equality--as opposed to the actual practice of it--that people who look like me purport to be stunned when presented with the idea that the equal treatment does not, in fact, exist, however well documented this reality may be.

One way to protest or mask the reality of racial oppression and its ramifications is to use the word "racism" to mean any prejudicial attitude by anyone of any "race" anywhere who feels superior in any way to someone of a different "race." That way, a European-American can point at an African-American who has buckled under his or her grief, frustration, and discouragment, finally becoming filled with bitterness and maybe even hatred toward the White establishment and those it privileges--and call that person of color a "racist." Which, in turn, allows White folks to declare, "See--anyone can be a racist."

The reason this doesn't hold for me is that, to start with, as I mentioned before (see "'Black.White.' Part Two or Keep My Name Out Your Mouth," March 4th), Europeans expressly constructed the very concept of "race" in the first place. And they didn't do it to make it easier to identify someone in a crowd either. They did it to create a hierarchy wherein people that look like me would automatically get the most of the best and the least of the worst--primarily by stealing from everybody else in one way or the other--while whoever was left got what they could, if anything. This was done for the purpose of making a very specific group of Europeans extremely rich. And White-controlled science, White-controlled law, and White-controlled religion worked together to legitimate this construct by announcing in no uncertain terms that White folks are superior to all other peoples on the face of the earth.

In other words, the very social construction of "race" itself was the act of White oppressors for the purpose of exploiting and dominating people of color. Having gone that far, some Europeans took their grandiose new status and proceeded to immigrate to North America, dragging with them millions of Africans, who they brutally and violently forced to build a new nation from the ground up for the benefit of its White citizens. It goes without saying, of course, that all of this new nation's social institutions, then, were originally established and have been continuously maintained by those with the power to define the culture--White people and those they allow into the inner circle.

This has not changed to date. We no longer drink at separate water fountains, it's true. But African-Americans, as a rule and across the board, because they don't have the power to do anything about it, are still paid less than White folks, own less than White folks, are more likely to be unemployed than White folks, are more likely to go to jail than White folks, etc., etc., ad nauseum. And most White folks are convinced that this is because people of color are, in fact, inferior. Let me repeat that: most White folks, yes, most White folks believe that people of color are, in fact, inferior. Even as they say, "I don't see color. I just see everyone as a human being," by which they mean, they don't intend to acknowledge all the studies showing how exploited and dominated people of color still are in the United States because the White speaker has already decided that Black people's problems are the result of Black people's inferiority. "Some of my best friends are Black," they will say, while discounting what African-Americans themselves say about the quality of their lives in the good old U.S. of A.

This rampant perception that people of color are inferior creates such a mindset that it's actually part of our national world view. We've taught ourselves to believe it for so long that we now think it's the natural truth. And to make matters worse, we've taught people of color to believe it, as well, in the face of overwhelming documentation to the contrary. Why do you think we dare not treat "African-American history" as a regular part of the history curriculum in this country rather than just breaking out Martin Luther King's "I Have a Dream" speech once a year in February? If people of color understood clearly who they are and what has been done to them, they would have long since burned this country down. And if White people were taught the truth of this nation's history and their own participation in and benefit from practices of White power and privilege, it would humble them so much that they might not recover.

Consequently, I (and I am not alone here) don't believe that it's possible for a person of color to be a racist. A Black person can be prejudiced against members of other groups, can be mean-spirited, can be cruel, can be hateful, can even be dangerous to members of other groups, but they have never had the power in the United States to define the nature of their own lives and therefore, to me, they're just being prejudicial, mean-spirited, cruel, hateful, and dangerous. The erroneous belief in White superiority and the inferiority of all others is directly responsible for the racist oppression that is entrenched and lethal in its daily application to the lives of people of color in this country today. It's no wonder African-Americans don't like White people. And since White people chose to construct the category of "race" in the first place specifically to gain from the denigration and destruction of other's lives, only White people, in my opinion, then, can be "racist."

18 comments:

Anonymous said...

here's a blog which I found interesting. I am curious to see the Wal-Mart movie at the next exam.

http://workingatwal-mart.blogspot.com/

Piscean Princess said...

Hey, why don't you send this one in for the Erase Racism carnival?

Changeseeker said...

I'd love to. I checked it out and couldn't figure out exactly how to determine the url for the particular post. And with the deadline eminent, I'm not sure I can pull it off. With your being on the same wave length, though (and WOW! do I feel GOOD about THAT!), I'll make another, more concerted effort. Thanks, Princess. Again.

Anonymous said...

My name is Lorraine. I am an anti-racist ally who stubbled across your blog by typing "Racism = Power + Prejudice" into Google.

It really thrills to find another white woman who has many of the same beliefs on racism as I. This had been a week of frustration for me, racism showing up everywhere and me having to talk about it, or defend my beliefs on it. I just recently saw the Michael Richards/Kramer video.....and people comments on that and their defense of his actions has really got me down.

I almost makes me cry to know that there are others like me out there, other whites who "get it." I have been active in my race and racism education for almost 6 years now, reading and learning all I can. I had my denial phase, my acceptance phase, and now I'm becoming angry....militant, if you want to use the word. I'm disgusted at my educational system for lying to me, I'm disgusted with my government for continuing to lie to people about race and racism, and I'm forming an ever-growing disgust for other white people and their attitudes towards race, and their lack of desire to be educated about it, to blow it off. I recently dismantled a friendship because a white friend of mine said something racist and I called her on it, and she actually said "Oh, whatever!" to me. It's been very hard, and I admit that I'm becoming just....mean to people because they don't want to understand, or even sometimes just because they don't understand. I don't believe that education can be done from a place of anger, and that's where I am right now.

I don't know how to "get over it," so to speak. But, regardless of that, it is an honor to meet you. And, I would really like to get to know you better. Even though you didn't do it on purpose, thank you for brightening my day. I feel better knowing there are people out there on my side. It reminds me that I can affect change.

Thank you for your work, your education, and your words. I will not forget it.

Changeseeker said...

Lorraine, your words--and your presence--are every bit as important to me as mine are to you. Believe me, much of the time, I'm in more or less the same space you are. My fuse is pretty short when it comes to the manifestations of White racism. Which is why I won't "discuss" it or "argue" with it on this blog. There's no point ("they" don't really want to listen) and it makes me crazy. Just imagine how people of color feel...

Anonymous said...

I am also in the same boat as Lorraine. I have just begun my journey toward wanting social change in society today and I know I have much more to learn about creating social change.

Sometimes I just want to scream at people, tell them why they should care and how one horrible act of racism, gender inequality, "wilding" ect, ect. can effect everyone. I have tried to explain to friends about what I have learned in my classes and how angry I get when I leave class knowing that I can't do much about the wrongs in the world because not even my friends will listen and take me seriously.

I also feel hurt knowing that the way i grew up (the paradigm)everything I was taught almost, was just a lie. My own country, that I was taught and grew to love, has no problem lying to me, exploiting my family who work for them and leaving them out to dry becasue they can just pick up, outsource, and pay other nations less. How can one voice attempt to tumble an entire lifetime of lies and indescretion? Is just seems an impossible task, even for the strongest of us all.

Jason said...

I feel some of your points are valid, mainly that "rich" europeans are the main cause of the problem at hand. But I feel your statement "Consequently, I (and I am not alone here) don't believe that it's possible for a person of color to be a racist." is exceptionally far from the truth. Any person can be racist no matter their color. Your view will continue the problem and only make the situation worse. Everyone needs to be treated as equals concerning race, ZERO exceptions! As for some of your comments concerning work and jail; your information appears to be tainted. I have witnessed many African-Americans come into a workplace for an interview at a blue collar job. Many time they arrive with their street clothes, pants sagging down the back, a hat on crooked with their best jewelry. By all appearences they do not care that they have a chance at something better. Many of those that are hired are eventually released due to poor work ethic (validated). Of those that apply from other races, they arrive in a professional manner. Why is this? As for being jailed, many minorities can get away with almost anything as long as the "race" card is pulled. Why is this? You say you have learned the truth of our country? I know you have just chosen the opposite view of the norm. Your viewpoint will perpetuate this problem to another civil war. What is needed is equal treatment under the law.

Cero said...

"Let me repeat that: most White folks, yes, most White folks believe that people of color are, in fact, inferior. Even as they say, "I don't see color. I just see everyone as a human being," by which they mean, they don't intend to acknowledge all the studies showing how exploited and dominated people of color still are in the United States because the White speaker has already decided that Black people's problems are the result of Black people's inferiority. "Some of my best friends are Black," they will say, while discounting what African-Americans themselves say about the quality of their lives in the good old U.S. of A.

This rampant perception that people of color are inferior creates such a mindset that it's actually part of our national world view. We've taught ourselves to believe it for so long that we now think it's the natural truth. And to make matters worse, we've taught people of color to believe it, as well, in the face of overwhelming documentation to the contrary. Why do you think we dare not treat "African-American history" as a regular part of the history curriculum in this country rather than just breaking out Martin Luther King's "I Have a Dream" speech once a year in February? If people of color understood clearly who they are and what has been done to them, they would have long since burned this country down. And if White people were taught the truth of this nation's history and their own participation in and benefit from practices of White power and privilege, it would humble them so much that they might not recover."

These are key words, and this is a great & really useful post.

Changeseeker said...

Thank you, cero. In truth, I think this post, written just three months after I started blogging, might be the cornerstone of everything I've blogged so far. And your zeroing in -- sorry, I couldn't help the pun :^) -- on these two paragraphs is no accident. They are, in my view, the crucial element at the base of the theory and praxis concerning the socially-constructed, political notion of "race" in the U.S. and always have been. One of my mentors, Korean sociologist and race theorist Won Moo Hurh wrote that as long as White Americans remain stuck, as it were, in what is apparently some manifestation of low self esteem, they will continue to NEED to designate "inferiors" as a mechanism to hold off descending into despair (or self-hatred?). I think I linked to this post the other day to re-center the blog and perhaps to encourage myself to think about this some more. Thanks (again) for stirring the pot.

Chicken Hammer said...

Wow what a reach. Only when we ALL treat each other equally will there be real equality. Making excused for the actions of one or another group does nothing to bring real equality to the table.

Changeseeker said...

Nobody's making excuses for anybody, Chicken Hammer, but when one group is standing on the neck of another group, to suggest that they both have to make nice is to ignore reality. Group Two may have to promise not to kill Group One for five hundred years of continued oppression, but Group One needs to get off Group Two's neck. It's no where NEAR the same.

See what I'm sayin'?

Anonymous said...

Great post.

If anybody wants to laugh out loud at hypocrisy and falseness (and also feel like one is watching Jerry Springer show online) check:

http://angrywhitedude.com/

XD

Jon said...

I've only given your entry a cursory reading (it is late, I'll read it for real tomorrow), but it seems interesting.

Having not read carefully enough, I'll take a risk and run my mouth. While the entry is interesting it also seems slightly myopic.

Please explain how only white people can be racist in asian countries. Or is it that racism does not exist outside of the west?

Changeseeker said...

Europeans crafted the socially-constructed, political notion of "race" in the first place five hundred years or so ago and have been maintaining -- with the help of their European-American cousins -- White Power and White Supremacy as social institutions ever since, I focus primarily on the binary issue of Black/White relations in the U.S. (what I know best). Europeans and European-Americans have spread this form of oppression very effectively and to great financial benefit. That others have learned and adopted the concept goes without saying. China, for example, is the new colonizer of the continent of Africa. But it doesn't change the basic realities of my analysis. My understanding of "race" is sound and once you fully grasp my ideas, they're easy to apply to a continuum of scenarios. Using the binary (Black/White) model gives folks a simple place to begin.

Anonymous said...

Great post! I very much agree with you.
I have one question for you, however. Since you've mentioned that you don't believe that black people can be racist (agreed, prejudiced yes, racist - no) would you extend the same sentiment to women? I mean the construct of 'race' and 'racism' was created by white men- for men, to emasculate 'other' men - with women never being considered equal. Do you agree?

(I'm like 3 years too late but I just came across this post)

Changeseeker said...

I never thought of it like that, Anon 7:03. I'll have to mull that over. It certainly is true that the White male power structure established and has maintained the social institutions (including institutionalizing both racism AND sexism in the U.S.), so in that sense, women were out of the loop. Nevertheless, women that look like me (no matter what their actual heritage) have benefitted greatly from the system of oppression against people of color and continue to do so to the present.

On the other hand, I always find it interesting to note that statistically, those African-American men who are allowed to have jobs make, on average, more than European-American women. White men are at the top with Black men second, White women third and Black women last in median income. So in the case of income, gender trumps race. Though, as I already pointed out, that only includes the Black men allowed to get jobs, stay out of prison, etc.

Anonymous said...

I cannot believe how incredibly skewed this view is. Only white people can be racist? Please. I can think of 5 people right now that don't like me because I'm white. I went to inner city schools as a kid. And don't even begin to pretend you have any idea of what true equality is. Equality is treating people EQUALLY, not treating one over the other, as you suggest. Not only will the view continue to perpetuate active as well as passive racism, but you are hurting your own cause by doing so.

Changeseeker said...

First of all, Anonymous 8:38, I don't have any "causes." I just believe in justice. You didn't get the point of this post because you sound as if you're stuck on wanting to keep things the way they are -- firmly entrenched in White privilege. Usually, when a really new idea is thrown at a person, it helps if they veeeery carefully read through the idea more than once until they understand what's being ssid (whether they agree with it or not).

For example, you apparently missed the line in my last paragraph that reads: "A Black person can be prejudiced against members of other groups, can be mean-spirited, can be cruel, can be hateful, can even be dangerous to members of other groups, but they have never had the power in the United States to define the nature of their own lives and therefore, to me, they're just being prejudicial, mean-spirited, cruel, hateful, and dangerous." From what you say, that's been your experience. I'm guessing that your attitude is at least partly WHY your experience has been that way.